This appears to be the correct answer, Meraki's network objects/object groups is the saving grace. Previously, technicians had attempted to use the Layer 3 firewall rules but got hung up on the fact that those rules don't affect S2S VPN traffic and thought they would have to create all the rules 2x. After some thinking, reading, and some testing we ended up with the following (high-level) approach: Enable Policy Objects (Beta) - there's a gotcha here where if you have too many objects in a group (or too many objects in general, I'm not certain) they won't all display in the Dashboard UI. The full list can be retrieved via the API though so it's no big deal Create an object for each subnet, done via API scripting As a side note, it would be nice if each object didn't need a 'name'. If no name is provided, the subnet address should be assumed as the name vs. requiring us to specify Create an object-group for each 'segment' and fill with individual objects belonging to that segment. For example the ~150 enterprise workstation subnets from my first post go into the EnterpriseWorkstations object group. Add objects to object-groups in order to control deployment Build S2S VPN firewall rules using the object-groups as the source/destinations. This reduces the # of individual rules by a vast amount, making them easier to visualize/review. Create 'default deny' rules for each object group where applicable (for the Phones or Printers object groups, as an example), factoring in the implicit allow at the bottom of the S2S VPN firewall ruleset On the LAN side, the ruleset is standard accross the board. Powershell script to poll each 'network' for local LANs, and splat in the ruleset for each local LAN. For example don't let the Phones subnet talk to the Printers subnet, etc. Nix the Layer 3 SVI Group Policies at each site as deployment rolls forward This seems to be working just fine at the five locations I've migrated to the deployment described above. Unsure what performance constraints I may see (particularly at the VPN Concentrators) as this moves forward. Will follow-up if I stumble across anything.
... View more