Meraki

ATS55 · ‎Sep 26 2023

Hello everyone,

I receive a message on Alert Hub that says "Access point has an ethernet negotiation failure" and it shows me the APs name related to this error message. My APs are all MR33, but only 4 APs are added to this error message.

Anybody has had the same issue?

Any comments?

Thank you

RaphaelL · ‎Sep 26 2023

Have you seen any link negotiation issues on your switch ?

Macguy · ‎Sep 26 2023

I just saw 8 Access Points on my Alert Hub with same message. Various AP models along with both Aruba and Meraki switches. Tried forcing 1Gb Full Duplex (didn't work) on switch. I'm going to try and get to one of the buildings tomorrow. Upon looking at port history, seems like this ethernet negotiation has been an issue. Maybe this alert setting was just added to the Alert Hub? Not sure. Will post follow up tomorrow.

PhilipDAth · ‎Sep 26 2023

What is the AP set to? auto/auto I hope?

What is the switch port set to? auto/auto I hope.

What speed and duplex are they reporting?

If you have a Meraki switch, do a cable test. What does it report?

Macguy · ‎Sep 26 2023

In my case Auto for both... Cable tests pass on Meraki switch. Reporting 100Mbps, should be 1Gbps. I'm going to do more testing tomorrow.

ATS55 · ‎Sep 26 2023

In my case the ports on the switches are set to auto negotiation. They passed 1 Gigabit and now they are passing 100 Megabit. I restart one of the APs and it didn't help. The issue is happening on different locations (of course different switches, too). Now, I have the alert on 8 APs. It seems the issue is spreading.

TBHPTL · ‎Sep 26 2023

You can't set speed and duplex from one side it has to be set the same on both sides. auto/auto or hardcoded same on each side

As @PhilipDAth stated:

"What is the AP set to? auto/auto I hope?"

"What is the switch port set to? auto/auto I hope."

ATS55 · ‎Sep 27 2023

I have checked that on the AP's local configuration (through my.meraki.com) and Meraki dashboard setting, but I didn't see any where I can change link speed. The only setting I'm able to change is on switch port setting. I will be happy if anybody shares their info where we can have access to the setting @TBHPTL mentioned.

TBHPTL · ‎Sep 27 2023

My comments about speed and duplex are in general.

https://documentation.meraki.com/MR/Other_Topics/Port_Link_Speed_of_Cisco_Meraki_Access_Points

Macguy · ‎Sep 27 2023

So this is super weird. Went to my elementary school, took AP negotiating at 100Mbps down. Plugged into my Mac laptop and instantly got connected at 1Gbps. I grabbed a spare MR46 and plugged that in with same cable. It connected/negotiated at 1Gbps. Left MR46 in classroom. Took the MR56 down to my IT office and connected to port on desk (connected to different Meraki Switch) and negotiated at 100Mbps. Going to open case with Meraki as it seems in my first example here it is the AP not cabling. I have seven more AP's like this to diagnose.

UPDATE - On phone with Meraki support and before doing an RMA we decided to do a factory reset on the AP. Sure enough, the AP remained stable and connected at 1Gbps after. I'll post updates with the other AP's accordingly.

agreen · ‎Sep 28 2023

Having the same issue on four MR46 and MR52 access points. I can confirm that factory reset has fixed three out of the four.

regz20 · ‎Sep 28 2023

Where do you initiate a factory reset? Meraki or to the switch port?

RaphaelL · ‎Sep 28 2023

On the AP.

https://documentation.meraki.com/General_Administration/Support/Resetting_Cisco_Meraki_Devices_to_Fa....

agreen · ‎Sep 28 2023

There's a reset button on the access point itself. It's usually next to the network port. You'll need something pointy. Leave it powered on, press the reset button for 5 seconds, it will reboot and reset.

Bill6 · ‎Sep 27 2023

We are having the same problem as OP

RaphaelL · ‎Sep 28 2023

We have 5K MR33/MR36. Actually 55 of them are negotiating at 100Mbps. However , all my cases are related to bad cabling ( did a cable test on every single one ).

So, have you tried doing a cable test as suggested by Phil earlier ?

randyjackson197 · ‎Sep 28 2023

We are also seeing this suddenly. We are running firmware 30.5 om MR46 WAPs. Could this be a firmware issue?

agreen · ‎Sep 28 2023

Mine are on MR29.5.1

Macguy · ‎Sep 28 2023

Don't think so... I have 29.5.1 and 29.7 with various AP models.

AlexisPinones · ‎Oct 6 2023

Los míos son MR 29.6.1 Modelo MR46E

Reseteando el SW Meraki tb, algunos vuelven.

Aunque el test de cable indicaba falla, los cables fueron certificados, probaremos ahora reestableciendo los AP que mantienen los inconvenientes.

Bill6 · ‎Sep 28 2023

I opened a ticket and was told this is a known issue and our ticket was added to the list. I would recommend anyone having this issue do the same. It was recommended to us that we roll back to the version 28 firmware, so Merakii did that for us and I haven't seen the problem since.

Macguy · ‎Sep 28 2023

Thanks for update. I posted question to my ticket asking about the "known issue". Not cool since 29.x fixes many issues we were having.

Ryan_Miles · ‎Oct 3 2023

I would recommend anyone having an issue open a Support case and not make any assumptions based on this thread. I checked the case mentioned below and it's not tied to any known issue around eth speeds on APs. The APs in that case show event log messages that point to another problem not eth speed related.

Ryan

If you found this post helpful, please give it Kudos. If my answer solves your problem please click Accept as Solution so others can benefit from it.

Macguy · ‎Sep 28 2023

What is your ticket number? My support tech just responded that he is "unaware of any known issues".

Bill6 · ‎Sep 28 2023

We have opened Case 10853438 for you.

Macguy · ‎Sep 29 2023

Just factory reset (3) MR56 AP's at my middle school all successfully negotiated at 1Gbps. Really wish you could factory reset remotely via GUI under tools. So far 4 out of 8 have been fixed with factory reset. I'll deal with the 4 next week.

ATS55 · ‎Sep 29 2023

As I have tested that on 2 of my APs so far, I found that we have connection issue on pair 3 and/or 4. I resolved the issues and the link speed changed from 100Mbit to 1000Mbit / 1Gbit. then the alerts for the two APs have gone. We had the link speed up to 100Mbit before, but Meraki never alerted us for that. It seems Meraki is stepping up to introduce higher than 1Gbit link speed.

Macguy · ‎Oct 2 2023

So last night I was messing with the remaining four AP's reporting 100Mbps. All I did was run a cable test on an MR56 and everything passed. Few seconds later the dashboard reported 1Gbps. I did nothing else. This is an AP that has been rebooted too. There are 3 AP's remaining in my environment and one appears to be cabling. I will factory reset the other two.

ATS55 · ‎Oct 2 2023

The thing is if you connection problem (layer 1), sometimes cable test or rebooting the device help. I have had the experience. But in my cases I had a serious connection issues.

ponzcruze · ‎Oct 2 2023

Having the same issue on four MR46 and MR52 access points.

SecurityFinance · ‎Oct 5 2023

Yes, we have about 800 AP's and all the sudden on Sept 27 at 18:32, about 38 of them all alerted on this issue. Bounced the port to reset them but still showing alert and syncing at 100Mbps. Meraki terrible support just acts like, ah, well, upgrade the code on them and see what happens. The other shotty tech wants us to go to them and factory reset them. Who's gonna pay to send a tech in to every locations affected and take the AP down from ceiling and factory reset them. You can't find anyone worth shooting these days. Aggravating to say the least and I hope it don't keep spreading to the rest of the AP's.

Macguy · ‎Oct 6 2023

I think what happened is they added this new alert to alert hub. The issues with 100Mbps were probably already there. But yes, physically going to each AP is annoying. I really wish they had a remote factory reset option in dashboard. We have 600 AP's and only 8 had this issue. Don't think this is a firmware bug.

antonis_sp · ‎Dec 14 2023

Fun fact, this has popped up on all the APs of one of our customers.

All APs have 100Mbit connections as they are connected to FastEthernet ports.

Waiting on support.

pjc · ‎Dec 15 2023

Yep, same here, hundreds of our AP's are reporting this error this morning, logged with support

Access point has an ethernet negotiation failure

pjc · ‎Dec 15 2023

Response from support including workaround. That's teach me to opt in to new features....

Thank you for contacting Meraki support.

We are currently aware of a issue that is causing false positive alerts due to a on-going issue that is being investigated with high priority. As a workaround please disable Opt-in to view and manage alerts in a new centralized Alert Page on the early access page until the issue is resolved to clear the alerts shown.

Once we have confirmed that the issue is resolved we will provide you a update.

antonis_sp · ‎Dec 15 2023

Got the same answer. Workaround is working for us.

Macguy · ‎Dec 15 2023

So in my case I did a firmware update to one of my middle schools this week and all of a sudden two AP's negotiated at 100Mbit (they were full 1000Mbit before upgrade). I got same alerts via org - alerts about negotiation failure. All I did was do a cable test on Meraki Switch and they magically negotiated at 1000Mbit.

BK53 · ‎Dec 15 2023

We had the exact same issue last night. Around 10pm GMT, 60 of our APs triggered offline alerts. It doesn't seem to be service impacting but at least it has flagged APs not negotiating at 1Gb.

We have a ticket open with Meraki, but appreciate the helpful updates you've all posted this morning.

MarkReader · ‎Dec 15 2023

Same issue here with 11 ap's that connect to a 100mbs switch port. Glad to hear it isn't just me!

RyanS1 · ‎Dec 15 2023

Not that this helps, but I had some access points and also had a couple switches say they were offline, but they really weren't. I turned off "opt-in to view and manage alerts in a new centralized alert page" under Organization - Early Access. It all went away and back to normal. I think it is just an interface issue and nothing really wrong with the equipment.

TheITguy · ‎Dec 15 2023

Same here, i turned this option off and on again, all the "Packet fragments detected" (switch) and "Access point has an ethernet negotiation failure" (access point) went away.

flaxzune · ‎Apr 7 2024

I just saw 8 Access Points on my Alert Hub with same message. Various AP models along with both Aruba and Meraki switches.

Alexander3 · ‎Apr 29 2024

I have like 57 devices in one network all showing warning "Access point has an ethernet negotiation failure" directly on the Access point page.
All are connected with only 100Mbit. Devices with Gbit connections seems ok.

Oropher · ‎Jun 11 2024

We are an important organisation and have hundreds of MR46 in production. I confirm this random issue, as many others in this post. Some APs are negotiating at 100 Mbps FastEthernet, not Gigabit. After some times, they are suddenly negotiating back to Gigabit. We have Meraki switches only. When we run the cable test from the console, it always finished without any error.

We have also this issue in a new buildings, with new wiring that has been checked with a professional network tester. The UTP cable connections is not shielded, so I'm wondering if shielded S/FTP cable is adviced to help with this issue.

If it's not a wiring issue, it should be adressed and analyzed by Cisco. They are too sensitive for normal prod conditions.