Hi @GIdenJoe ,
Those are some valid points you make. And there are certain business and use cases where an Airgap soultion is better suited than Cloud based. However, I would argue that;
- "CLI you immediately now at what command you just fumbled". This is not always the case. In the Configuration Shell the problem might not error or be seen in Syslog at all. E.g. if there is a certain traffic flow conditions being hit and the configuration is 'correct' you won't be able to see it from that Shell. i.e. Logs will need to be pulled from the controllers on the Line Card or Module directly. This can be very tedious & time consuming to discover this condition at all.
- Regarding the disconnects to Magagement and or the devices. I have certaily worked on cases where, sites are out in the sticks, only have Sateliete (RTT of 300ms) and perfrom very well all things condisered. That customer had the the proper design considerations in place to achieve this. i.e. VLAN Pruning, STP following best practice, traffic shaping policy in place. etc.
Yes, things can go wrong sometimes. Which is why i love the Dashabord, because you can very quickly discover these then spend the time drilling into root cause.
Just my Two Cents.
Cheers,
Ivan Jukić,
Meraki APJC
If you found this post helpful, please give it kudos. If it solved your problem, click "accept as solution" so that others can benefit from it.