RTSP camera link to Access Control only uses ONVIF

[Dscott84]

I am trying to link some of my Meraki Cameras to my access control system. I am having to use RTSP to do this, but when I add the camera IP into my access control system and then attempt to view the camera, a popup windows comes up telling me that I need to install the VLC Media Player extension (which no longer exists).  I contacted the access control software people and they told me that their system will play any camera that connects via IP and uses ONVIF.

So, is this something that Meraki MV cameras are not capable of doing, or am I doing something wrong?

If I connect to the camera directly through a player like VLC, I can access a live stream via RTSP, so it seems to be the IP connection with the access control system.

All of this is being done on an internal LAN for my network.

[alemabrahao]

It's probably something on your server, RTSP for Meraki MV is very simple.

[GreenMan]

Meraki MV cameras do not support ONVIF.   Other than RTSP to make the video stream available, the MV system is designed to be proprietary, to ensure it's high degree of security, reliability and ease-of-use.   Do you have Meraki licensing for your MV cameras?   If so, you'd conduct all of your management for the system through the Meraki Dashboard or the related Vision Portal.

API-based capabilities also allow a high degree of secure integration with vision-related systems

[WWong]

Hi @GreenMan , does Meraki camera send out RTSP stream via TCP or UDP?

[GreenMan]

Good Q, not covered by the documentation.   I set up a quick pcap on my MS switch;   with my MV72 , running MV 5.3 firmware, the RTSP is all TCP, port 9000   Tested with VLC

[WWong]

Thanks much @GreenMan. And just to confirm there is no way to configure the camera to utilize UDP?

[PhilipDAth]

These are your only configuration options.

@GreenMan , did you also try telling VLC to connect via UDP as well (it defaults to TCP)?  Perhaps it supports both.

[GreenMan]

Use RTP over RTSP (TCP) was already unchecked.   Admittedly, I didn't capture the very first stream between my machine and the camera (so maybe there's some dynamic settings caching going on), but I see no UDP traffic between the two, when starting streams now - not even an initial 'give UDP a go'.   I may retest later, when I can fully restart my PC

[cincinnatiman]

dhcp and dns come in on udp ports,   now i know this never been even consider but is it possable sent rtsp over port 53 udp,    now i got 3 camreas i getting ready set up, and i can get up to date software for poe swich,

so only quistion becomes can the stream be sent over port 53. 136 500 each these ports required as well ports 67 and 68  it would be a intresting test to see if it could be done,    i do know for fack that they can use port 53 udp to set up vpn for hacking,

saying this why cant streaming be sent over same port,   only probem i might see is with a busness domain or other dns servers,   but ports offten run more one protocall over them, this wold be worth testing, as if it could work, would solve ton probems,one could run these on diffrent vlan and use port forwarding to that vlan not ever been consider but worth to try

[PhilipDAth]

It looks like H.264 encoding is used.

https://documentation.meraki.com/MV/Advanced_Configuration/MV_Encoding_Improvements%3A_Smart_Codec 

That's an industry standard ...

[cincinnatiman]

so you could get a cisco system used for video confercacing, then you convert the video to anything you want, with video capture card,  or  other,  i meen all protocalls start with H are used for video audio conferaceing and or phones, as the compreshion rate not to be confused with rtsp now here interesting quistion can cisco video confenaceing servrs handle rtsp ,   now from what i understand video trasport dose not happen over rtsp rather this is a seed to send it along another protocall,    so in short device must support bouth or will fail,  also u need layer 3 swich not one at bestby, it must handle higer bandwith used by video,  

O by way one thing we all forgot all cisco camers also trasfers all video feeds to ftp sever,  all one needs do is stream live from ftp server probem solved