BiDi optics in MX applicance

SOLVED
JimR
Conversationalist

BiDi optics in MX applicance

Does anyone have experience using BiDi optics on an MX84? I see "compatible" modules on Amazon but no OEM options. 

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION
jdsilva
Kind of a big deal

Alright, my memory is a bit off. We use the Lumentum and LambdaGain BiDi's in the MS switches and they work fine. But, it appears on a quick test that the LambdaGains DO NOT work in the MX line. 

 

I tested between an MX84 and MS410. The following info is from the MS410 side since we can't see port info on an MX 😞

 

This worked in an MX84:

 

image.png

IMG_20190326_105155.jpg

 

 

But the LambdGain does not:

 

image.png

IMG_20190326_105305.jpg

View solution in original post

9 REPLIES 9
jdsilva
Kind of a big deal

Yup. We've used BiDi's from both Lumentum and LambdaGain. They work well.

Thanks for confirming @jdsilva just wanted to confirm that's on SFP ports 11/12 of an MX84 for example?  I thought there may not be hardware support for BiDi, but perhaps that's on the WAN interfaces of MX250/450 perhaps.

jdsilva
Kind of a big deal

@MerakiDave I can't say for sure if we have any BiDi's in an MX84... But I have one in my lab I can test with if you're curious?

Thanks @jdsilva I was looking to confirm your BiDi's were working on LAN vs WAN side of MX250/450, I don't have that lab gear and wasn't sure if BiDi might work on the LAN side only, or work on both LAN/WAN ports. I heard mixed results but that was over a year ago, and given your note/caveat above, perhaps there's better support now. I could check with MX PM team but sounds like you're already doing it.
jdsilva
Kind of a big deal

I'm testing this out quickly just to make sure. Standby. 

jdsilva
Kind of a big deal

Alright, my memory is a bit off. We use the Lumentum and LambdaGain BiDi's in the MS switches and they work fine. But, it appears on a quick test that the LambdaGains DO NOT work in the MX line. 

 

I tested between an MX84 and MS410. The following info is from the MS410 side since we can't see port info on an MX 😞

 

This worked in an MX84:

 

image.png

IMG_20190326_105155.jpg

 

 

But the LambdGain does not:

 

image.png

IMG_20190326_105305.jpg

JimR
Conversationalist

Thanks for all of the info guys! I am extremely impressed with the quick response and knowledgeable answers.
jdsilva
Kind of a big deal

One caveat though, that applies to MX SFP's in general, is that we've found that the out of the box firmware on the MX250/450 often doesn't have proper support for certain SFPs on the WAN ports, or the SFP+ ports. My recommendation is to connect those models specificially to the cloud using a 1000Base-T SFP first, upgrade the firmware, and then you're good to go.

@jdsilva I don't have any MX250/450 or BiDi to test with, just wanted to confirm if you successfully used those 3rd party BiDi optics on both LAN and WAN (with the caveat you noted) or perhaps just the LAN side?

Get notified when there are additional replies to this discussion.
Welcome to the Meraki Community!
To start contributing, simply sign in with your Cisco account. If you don't yet have a Cisco account, you can sign up.
Labels