We had the same NO-PROPOSAL-CHOSEN error on the remote side of the Site to Site VPN. We have found that with Load Balancing enabled and Active-Active AutoVPN set to Enabled, the Non-Meraki VPN peers can still only be established on whatever interface is set as the Primary uplink on the SD-WAN & Traffic shaping page. We resolved the NO-PROPOSAL-CHOSEN error by using the correct Public IP of the MX on the remote side of the tunnel.
... View more