Hi @averythomas, The only way I can think of at the moment to allow this would be to have a different vLan for each AP SSID/Apple TV setup. Then you could enable the forwarding for AirPrint and not set forwarding for AirPlay. As long as your clients on that AP/SSID are on the same vLan as your Apple TV, it should show available (as long as firewall rules allow it) and you can see all available AirPrint printers on the vLan that is forwarded.
... View more